Skip to ContentSkip to Footer
Logo_Original_72dpi
Contact Us
Protect What You Love
With A Name You Trust

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Our Insurance Products

Auto Insurance

Home Insurance

Life Insurance

Business Insurance

Drew-Matthews-Headshot
Drew Matthews
President

Matthews Family Insurance specializes in home, auto, and business insurance.

Insuring Indianapolis and All of Indiana

Let our family help you protect yours. At Matthews Family Insurance our goal is to help you navigate the world of insurance and use our years of experience to help you find the right solution for you and your family.

Erie Insurance Logo
The Progressive Corporation Logo
Colonial Life & Accident Insurance Logo
Openly Insurance Logo
Humana, Inc. Logo
SILAC Insurance Company Logo
North America Logo
Specializing In Erie Insurance
Erie Insurance has been helping customers since 1925 with their auto, home, business, and life insurance needs.
Get an Auto Quote
Get an Auto Quote
Pay Your Bill
Pay Your Bill
Life Insurance Calculator
Life Insurance Calculator
Access Online Account
Access Online Account
AE
Rated 5 out of 5

Go see Matt for any insurance needs! He was a Godsend to my family and I. After...

Amanda E.
JT
Rated 5 out of 5

5 stars!

Jeffrey T.
LM
Rated 5 out of 5

Drew was fantastic to work with- he saved us $600 a year on homeowner and auto...

Lindy M.
BW
Rated 5 out of 5

Drew was wonderful! He takes care of everything. I've never had car insurance...

Bryan W.
Laura Leachman
Rated 5 out of 5

Matthews Home Insurance has been a huge sigh of a relief for me as a single...

Laura L.
See All Reviews

Recent News & Updates

Medicare Part D: Understanding Prescription Drug Coverage
August 6, 2026
​What to Do After a Hit and Run​
August 4, 2026
When Should I Call My Insurance Agent?
August 4, 2026
erie-logo-reverse

ERIE's Your Turn® Program

There is a new way Erie Insurance is looking out for you and wants to help you stay safe on the road.
learn more